Friday, March 28, 2008
Monday, August 6, 2007
Popperism
I think Karl Popper is right. We can never really know the truth. All we can know is what cannot be falsified today and tomorrow someone will falsify some of what we believe in today.
Oh come now. You cannot be serious. Consider the innumerable and indisputable truths you embrace at this instant without even thinking about them as you read this post, from the solidity of your chair, to the existence of the television in the next room, to the names of your parents, and so on. Only in the most narrow scientific sense is Popper right.
Oh come now. You cannot be serious. Consider the innumerable and indisputable truths you embrace at this instant without even thinking about them as you read this post, from the solidity of your chair, to the existence of the television in the next room, to the names of your parents, and so on. Only in the most narrow scientific sense is Popper right.
Labels: truth
Sunday, August 5, 2007
Necessary Lies
Knowing when to tell the truth and when not to shows good judgment.
There are the acceptable lies of etiquette. They are acceptable because they allow social relationships to operate and even perform. If you see a stout woman, for example, you don't ask he when the blessed event will occur unless you really know she is pregnant, or if she is proud of her grandchildren, when they may be her children! That is a case of perhaps not knowing the real truth-- that she isn't pregnant and is the mother of the kids. But even when you do know the truth, you don't articulate the truth, as in: "Your body smell is unusually rank today and, by the way, here is my social security number." I think some of what passes for religion in distinction to spirituality and ethics comes under this heading. I was invited to a bat mitvah, and, although I'm not Jewish, I prayed and recited along with the rest. An act of dishonesty? No, it was an act of respect and, as you mention, judgment.
There are the acceptable lies of etiquette. They are acceptable because they allow social relationships to operate and even perform. If you see a stout woman, for example, you don't ask he when the blessed event will occur unless you really know she is pregnant, or if she is proud of her grandchildren, when they may be her children! That is a case of perhaps not knowing the real truth-- that she isn't pregnant and is the mother of the kids. But even when you do know the truth, you don't articulate the truth, as in: "Your body smell is unusually rank today and, by the way, here is my social security number." I think some of what passes for religion in distinction to spirituality and ethics comes under this heading. I was invited to a bat mitvah, and, although I'm not Jewish, I prayed and recited along with the rest. An act of dishonesty? No, it was an act of respect and, as you mention, judgment.
Labels: truth

